HKU Logo

Home > Topics > Daily Lives Legal Issues > Domestic helper issues

I. General

Hong Kong is a vibrant economy where almost all available and eligible persons are in the work force. This means that many families will have to delegate their household chores to domestic helpers. The most common form of obtaining the service of a domestic helper is either through engaging a part-time local worker or a full-time foreign domestic helper. The latter is probably the predominant practice adopted by most households in Hong Kong.

Despite the large number of domestic helpers in Hong Kong, in particular foreign domestic helpers earning their living here, there is no statutory law exclusively governing matters related to their employment. The Employment Ordinance ( Chapter 57 of the Laws of Hong Kong) remains the major statue governing all matters in relation to employment. In essence, the Employment Ordinance covers all employees, whether temporary, part-time or full-time. It also covers all foreign domestic helpers working in Hong Kong. Put it simply, all domestic helpers, as with all employees, are entitled to the basic employment rights, for example, statutory holidays, wage protection, protection against anti-union discrimination, etc.

For general employment matters, readers may refer to the topic of “ Employment Disputes ” under the CLIC website. Here we shall focus only on issues specifically applicable to the employment of domestic helpers.

II. Test What the employer of a local domestic helper must know

A local domestic helper basically enjoys the same rights that any employee enjoys under the Employment Ordinance. Even if the local domestic helpers work on part-time basis, such rights do not falter. However, there is one factor that an employer frequently overlooks: the possibility that the helper may sustain injury during his/her work.

Let’s imagine the following scenario: a local domestic helper came to an employer’s home to do some cleaning and household chores a few times a week. The helper did the work; the employer made the payment; both parties were happy; that sounds simple and straight-forward. Now what if the helper suffers injuries at the employer’s home and claims the employer for damages? And what if the injury is very serious or even fatal? Wouldn’t it be advisable for the employer to get some insurance against such incident?

As a matter of fact, it is not simply advisable to obtain such insurance; it is mandatory. In Hong Kong, it is compulsory for an employer to be in possession of a valid insurance policy to cover his/her liabilities in respect of work injuries sustained by his/her employees.

Under section 40 of the Employees’ Compensation Ordinance ( Chapter 282 of the Laws of Hong Kong), no employer shall employ any employee in any employment unless there is in force in relation to such employee an insurance policy issued by an insurer for an amount not less than the amount specified in the said Ordinance in respect of the liability of the employer. This also applies to employment of local part-time domestic helpers.

An employer who fails to take out an employees’ compensation insurance for his/her employee(s) commits a criminal offence and shall be liable to a fine up to HK$100,000 and to imprisonment up to 2 years.

There are insurers who provide part-time domestic helper insurance plans on a daily, weekly or monthly basis. Employers are advised to make enquires and to take out the relevant employees’ compensation insurance policies to comply with the law and to protect their part-time domestic helpers against the employers’ liability in the course of employment.

III. What the employer of a foreign domestic helper must know: An overview

Due to the fact that a foreign domestic helper is “imported”, his/her working status is slightly different from an ordinary employee in Hong Kong. Therefore, apart from the general matters applicable to the usual employment relationship, an employer of a foreign domestic helper has to be aware of the issues as listed in the following sections.

IV. Basic requirement for employing a foreign domestic helper

An employer has to show that he/she is financially capable of employing a foreign domestic helper. The minimum requirement is that the employer must have a household income of at least HK$15,000 per month so as to entitle him/her to engage a foreign domestic helper.

Details of eligibility criteria are stated in Guidebook for the Employment of Domestic Helpers from Abroad in the Immigration Department’s website.

V. The Standard Employment Contract for foreign domestic helpers

The Government has published an Employment Contract (For a Domestic Helper recruited from abroad) as an official employment contract for all foreign domestic helpers in Hong Kong. All the basic rights and responsibilities of a foreign domestic helper can be found in this standard Employment Contract, a specimen of which can be found at the Immigration Department’s website .

VI. Minimum allowable wage

Every foreign domestic helper is entitled to a monthly salary not less than the minimum allowable wage, which is currently HK$4,410 per month. Clause 5 of the standard Employment Contract expressly provides that “An employer who fails to pay the wages due under this employment contract shall be liable to criminal prosecution.”

Even if a foreign domestic helper agrees to accept a lower wage, an employer cannot pay anything less than the minimum allowable wage. Under section 63C of the Employment Ordinance (Cap. 57), an employer who pays less than the minimum allowable wage is liable, upon conviction, to a maximum fine of HK$350,000 and three years’ imprisonment. Since the employer would have contracted under the standard Employment Contract to pay at least the minimum allowable wage, failure to comply with the Employment Contract could lead to false representation to an Immigration Officer, which carries a maximum fine of $150,000 and imprisonment for 14 years (section 42 of the Immigration Ordinance, Cap. 115). If the employer and the helper agree to a lower wage, by virtue of common law and the Crimes Ordinance (Cap. 200) both of them may be conspiring to defraud and is liable to imprisonment for 14 years.

VII. Other employment engaged by foreign domestic helpers

Clause 4 of the standard Employment Contract expressly states that a foreign domestic helper “shall not take up, and shall not be required by the Employer to take up, any other employment with any other person” . This also forms part of the conditions of stay to be imposed on the foreign domestic helper by the Immigration Department upon the foreign domestic helper’s admission to work in Hong Kong. Any breach of this condition of stay would render the foreign domestic helper liable to criminal prosecution and removal from Hong Kong. The employer, who aids and abets the foreign domestic helper to breach a condition of stay, is also liable to prosecution and upon conviction, the maximum penalty will be a fine up to HK$50,000 and imprisonment for two years.

Under the Government’s policy, a foreign domestic helper is admitted into Hong Kong for employment with a specific employer to perform domestic duties at such employer’s residence.

In other words, an employer cannot ask his/her foreign domestic helper to go to his/her parents’ place to help, even though they may be living next door. Similarly one cannot ask your neighbour’s foreign domestic helper to come to work part-time at your place, even though you are willing to pay and the helper is happy to earn some extra money.

In contrast, there is no such restriction on the employment of local part-time domestic helpers. Therefore, an employer may consider employing a local domestic helper to work part-time for him/her.

VIII. Foreign domestic helpers can only perform domestic duties

Clause 4 of the standard Employment Contract provides that a foreign domestic helper “shall only perform domestic duties” for the employer. This Clause 4 also forms part of the conditions of stay to be imposed on the foreign domestic helper by the Immigration Department upon the foreign domestic helper’s admission to work in Hong Kong. Any breach of this condition of stay will render the foreign domestic helper liable to criminal prosecution and removal from Hong Kong. The employer, who aids and abets the foreign domestic helper to breach a condition of stay, is also liable to prosecution and upon conviction, the maximum penalty is a fine up to HK$50,000 and imprisonment for two years.

But what exactly is “domestic duties”? Clause 3 of the standard Employment Contract states that a foreign domestic helper “shall work and reside in the Employer’s residence” . Does it mean that the helper cannot do any work outside the residence, meaning that the helper cannot go to supermarket to buy food, nor go to the garage to wash the car, nor to bring garbage to the collection station? That obviously is stretching the interpretation too far. According to the Schedule of Accommodation and Domestic Duties as attached to the Standard Employment Contract, domestic duties include:

  1. household chores;
  2. cooking;
  3. looking after aged persons in the household;
  4. baby-sitting; and
  5. child-minding.

While this may not be very helpful, it is probably unrealistic to list all domestic duties in details on the Schedule of Accommodation and Domestic Duties since domestic duties can be sundry in types. Whether a duty required to be performed is considered to be domestic in nature must depend on the facts of each case. In any event, some duties to be performed outside an employer’s residence will be considered incidental to household chores, e.g. car-washing, buying groceries and bringing the employer’s children to school. However, to address the genuine needs of some employers, a special arrangement is made to allow foreign domestic helpers to perform driving duties which are incidental to and arising from domestic duties. Application may be made to the Director of Immigration for such special permission.

An employer should also note that a foreign domestic helper shall only be required to work in the employer’s residence at an address specified in Clause 3 of the Standard Employment Contract. In other words, if an employer owns several flats, he/she can ask the foreign domestic helper to work at only one household at one location.

IX. Living and meal arrangements

A. Residence of the foreign domestic helper

Clause 3 of the standard Employment Contract provides that the foreign domestic helper shall reside in the employer’s residence. In other words, an employer cannot ask the helper to reside at another place even if the employer is prepared to pay for that.

If employers or helpers breach the undertaking that the helper would work and reside in the employer’s residence, such conduct will be taken into consideration in their future foreign domestic helper visa or extension of stay applications. The applications may thus be refused.

Besides, it is an offence to make false representation to Immigration Officers upon the application of domestic helper visa. Offenders are liable to prosecution and to a maximum fine of $150,000 and imprisonment for 14 years.

B. Food allowance

Since the foreign domestic helper will be living together with the employer, it is the employer’s duty to provide food free of charge to the helper. If no food is provided, the employer shall provide a food allowance to the helper. The current minimum food allowance is HK$1,053 per month.

X. Insurance

A. Compulsory Insurance Policy: Employees’ Compensation Policy

In Hong Kong, it is compulsory for an employer to be in possession of a valid insurance policy to cover his/her liabilities in respect of work injuries sustained by his/her employees.

Under section 40 of the Employees’ Compensation Ordinance ( Chapter 282 of the Laws of Hong Kong), no employer shall employ any employee in any employment unless there is in force in relation to such employee an insurance policy issued by an insurer for an amount not less than the amount specified in the said Ordinance in respect of the liability of the employer. This also applies to employment of foreign domestic helpers.

An employer who fails to take out an employees’ compensation insurance for his/her employee(s) commits a criminal offence and shall be liable to a fine up to HK$100,000 and to imprisonment up to 2 years.

B. Medical and travel insurance

In addition to employees’ compensation insurance policy which is compulsorily required, employers should consider taking out other kinds of insurance policy which may be relevant to the employment of domestic helpers, such as medical insurance and travel insurance policies.

1. Medical insurance

An employer of a foreign domestic helper has the obligation to pay for the medical fees and expenses incurred by the helper. According to Clause 9 of the standard Employment Contract, “In the event the Helper is ill or suffers personal injury during the period of employment…except for the period during which the Helper leaves Hong Kong of his/her own volition and for his/her own personal purposes, the Employer shall provide free medical treatment to the Helper. Free medical treatment includes medial consultation, maintenance in hospital and emergency dental treatment.”

In such circumstances, although it is not compulsory to take out a medical insurance policy for a foreign domestic helper, an employer should seriously consider doing so, where both parties will enjoy a better protection in case of medical incidents suffered by the helper.

2. Travel insurance

It is not uncommon for employers in Hong Kong to bring along their foreign domestic helpers to take care of their children or elderly family members while they travel to the mainland or overseas with their families.

There is no prohibition against foreign domestic helpers following their employers to such trips and working for their employers outside Hong Kong. The conditions of stay in respect of a foreign domestic helper apply only whilst he/she is in Hong Kong. As such, a foreign domestic helper may follow his/her employer to go abroad on a mutual consent basis.

However, if a foreign domestic helper does follow his/her employer to go abroad, the employer should pay particular attention to the insurance arrangements. If the foreigner domestic helper gets injured during the course of employment in the destination country or territory, he/she may claim compensation in accordance with the employees’ compensation law of that country or territory. In other words, the employee may choose to claim under the laws of that foreign country or that of Hong Kong. Hence, an employer should check whether the employees’ compensation insurance policy taken out covers liabilities and compensation for injuries sustained when working abroad; and if it does not cover the same, the employer should consider taking out relevant insurance policies, such as travel insurance policy, for the domestic helper.

Moreover, both the employer and the foreign domestic helper should observe the relevant visa requirements as well as the laws and regulations of the destination country or territory.

XI. Injury sustained by the foreign domestic helper

If an accident happens to a domestic helper during his/her course of employment and he/she sustains serious injury, the employer should notify the insurer as soon as possible and in any event, within the stipulated time as required under the insurance policy.

If the domestic helper suffers injury during his/her course of employment, he/she may be entitled to claim against the employer. The parties may of course settle the claim on their own; or the insurance may be able to cover the claim. But if no settlement can be reached or if the claim is not covered by insurance, the employee may choose to take legal action against the employer. If the employer receives any demand letter or a writ of summons issued by the court, he/she should notify the insurer as soon as possible and should seek legal advice.

XII. Termination/renewal of employment contract

A. Termination of the employment by notice or payment in lieu

Under Clause 2 of the standard Employment Contract, the term of employment of a foreign domestic helper shall be a period of two years commencing either on:-

  1. the date on which the helper arrives at Hong Kong;
  2. a specified date which is the date following the expiry of the previous employment contract with the same employer; or
  3. the date on which the Director of Immigration grants the helper permission to remain in Hong Kong to begin employment under the employment contract.

Nevertheless, according to clause 10 of the standard Employment Contract, either the employer or the foreign domestic helper may terminate the employment relationship prior to its expiry by giving not less than one month’s notice in writing or by paying one month’s wages to the other party in lieu of notice.

B. Termination of the employment without notice or payment in lieu

Under exceptional circumstances, either the employer or the foreign domestic helper may terminate the employment contract without notice or payment in lieu of notice.

An employer may summarily dismiss a foreign domestic helper without notice or payment in lieu of notice if the helper, in relation to his/her employment:-

  1. wilfully disobeys a lawful and reasonable order;
  2. misconducts himself/herself;
  3. is guilty of fraud or dishonesty; or
  4. is habitually neglectful in his/her duties.

However, employers should note that summary dismissal is a serious disciplinary action. It only applies to cases where a foreign domestic helper has committed very serious misconduct or fails to improve after the employer’s repeated warnings.

On the other hand, a foreign domestic helper may terminate his/her employment contract without notice or payment of wages in lieu of notice if:

  1. he/she reasonably fears physical danger by violence or disease;
  2. he/she is subjected to ill-treatment by the employer; or
  3. he/she has been employed for not less than 5 years and he/she is certified by a registered medical practitioner as being permanently unfit for the type of work he/she is engaged.

C. Notice to the Director of Immigration

If the employment relationship between an employer and a foreign domestic helper is terminated prior to the expiry of the contracted period (whether it is by notice, by payment in lieu or by immediate termination), both the employer and the foreign domestic helper shall notify the Director of Immigration by way of a Notification of Termination of Employment Contract with Foreign Domestic Helper within seven days of the date of termination.

A foreign domestic helper is permitted to remain in Hong Kong for not more than two weeks after premature termination of the employment contract. If the foreign domestic helper does not leave upon the expiry of stay, he/she will commit an offence for breaching his/her condition of stay. An employer should not do anything to facilitate the foreign domestic helper’s overstaying in Hong Kong, for example by agreeing not to inform the Director of Immigration of the premature termination of the employment contract. Such an act could make the employer liable for aiding and abetting the foreign domestic helper to breach a condition of stay by overstaying. Upon conviction, this may lead to a fine of HK$50,000 and imprisonment for 2 years.

D. Other payment, rights and benefits upon termination

In respect of termination of employment contracts, foreign domestic helpers enjoy the same protection as any employees under the Employment Ordinance. For example, he/she is entitled to receive:

  1. all outstanding wages;
  2. wages in lieu of notice (if applicable);
  3. payment in lieu of any untaken annual leave, and any pro rata annual leave pay for the current leave year;
  4. payment in lieu of any untaken statutory holidays; and
  5. where appropriate, long service payment or severance payment.

However, since the foreign domestic helper is “imported” into Hong Kong, an employer shall be responsible for sending him/her back to his/her country of origin upon the termination or expiry of an employment contract by providing him/her with free return passage to his/her place of origin. 

Moreover, a daily food and travelling allowance of HK$100 per day shall be paid to the foreign domestic helper from the date of his/her departure from Hong Kong until the date of his/her arrival to his/her place of origin. As for the number of days for calculating the food and travelling allowance payable to the foreign domestic helper, it should be based on the time of journey by the most direct route. Generally speaking, for a foreign domestic helper whose place of origin is a country in Asia, allowance for one or two days would be reasonable and adequate.

There is no fixed rule as to whether an open-date air ticket or a fixed-date ticket shall be provided to the foreign domestic helper for his/her return flight. It is subject to the parties’ negotiation and agreement. It is not uncommon that some employers and their foreign domestic helpers may agree that money could be paid in lieu of the air ticket. The law does not prohibit such practice. But the employer should ensure that the details of the agreement are put into writing so that there is little room for dispute in the future.

E. Renewal of employment contract

If both the employer and the foreign domestic helper agree to renew an existing contract, the helper shall nevertheless return to his/her place of origin for a vacation of at least 7 days at the expense of the employer before the new contract commences. It means that the employer will have to provide a return air ticket to the helper in such scenario.

F. “Blacklist” kept at the Immigration Department?

There is always sayings that the Immigration Department has kept a “black list” of employers who has adverse record in respect of employment of foreign domestic helpers, for example one who has sacked many helpers within a short period of time, one who has been in breach of the standard Employment Contract, one who has been convicted of offence under the Employment Ordinance, etc.  The Immigration Department certainly retains a record of all employments of domestic helpers; and it certainly can easily access the record of any individual employer in this respect. But it would be going too far to say that there is a “black list”, by which certain employers would automatically be barred from employing a foreign domestic helper. The Director of Immigration, who has a wide discretion to assess the eligibility of each application for employment of a foreign domestic helper, will evaluate each application on a case by case basis.

 

 

XIII. Some other commonly envisaged issues

A. Deduction of wages?

Your domestic helper was quite helpful in doing household works, but was a bit careless and frequently broke your dishes, cups, your kid’s toys, etc. Can you deduct the value of these items from the helper’s wages?

The law allows an employer to make deductions for damage or loss to the employer’s goods or property directly attributable to the helper’s negligence or default. This right to deduction, however, is subject to the limit of HK$300 for each damaged item. So even if your domestic helper flushed your diamond ring down the toilet, you can at most deduct HK$300 from his/her salary.

Further, the total of such deductions shall not exceed one quarter of the wages payable to the helper in that wage period. For example, if you are paying your foreign domestic helper the monthly salary of HK$4,410, and if he/she negligently broke 5 valuable porcelain items (each worth more than HK$300) in a month, you can at most deduct HK$1,102.50 (being one quarter of HK$4,410), not HK$1,500 (being HK$300 x 5 items) from the helper’s salary for this month.

Well, you may argue: can I deduct HK$900 from this month’s salary, and then HK$600 from next month’s salary? After all, section 32 of the Employment Ordinance (Chapter 57 of the Laws of Hong Kong) only says that “the total of such deductions in any one wage period shall not exceed one quarter of the wages payable to the employee in respect of that wage period”; it does not specify that all deductions have to be made within one wage period. Your argument may seem cogent; yet the words “the total of such deductions” suggest that such “total” should correspond with the damage/loss incurred within the same “wage period”. It is believed that the Court will adopt this approach if being asked to interpreted section 32 of the Employment Ordinance.

B. Installation of camera inside your home

You wanted to install a camera inside your home so that you can monitor your domestic helper’s acts during your absence. But you wondered whether this would infringe the law on privacy.

Your worry is fully justified. But a further question to be asked is: what exactly is meant by privacy? It is beyond dispute that a toilet/bathroom or the domestic helper’s private room is a private place; and no camera can be installed at such area. But what about the living room, an area where anyone in your household can access anytime? Basically a person cannot have any privacy if he/she is in an environment where anyone can see him/her. For example, if a reporter takes a photo of a pedestrian jaywalking and posts that photo on a newspaper, the pedestrian cannot complain that his/her privacy has been infringed. Similarly, the living room of your home can be considered a “public” place because everyone in your household can freely access this area anytime. Therefore, a camera installed at the living room should not infringe the privacy of anyone.

However, it can also be argued that the domestic helper may do some private thing in your living room when nobody is at home; videotaping activities at the living room may therefore constitute intrusion upon his/her privacy. Therefore, it is suggested that employers should conduct the video monitoring by overt means, for example by telling the helper about the camera or by setting the camera at an unhidden location. It is only under exceptional circumstances that covert videotaping should be adopted. For example, if you seriously suspect and have evidence that young children or elderly persons at your home are being abused, you may consider using covert means, for example hidden camera, to monitor your domestic helper’s activities.

C. Child abuse or theft

If you have concrete evidence that your domestic helper has abused your child or has stolen your property, do not hesitate to report the case to the police. These are criminal activities and should not be pardoned nor be settled by private means.

If you do not have concrete evidence but suspect that your domestic helper has abused your child or has stolen your property, you may as well report the case to the police. It is the police’s duty, not yours, to conduct investigation on any suspicious case. An alternative is that you may try to gather more evidence, for example by installing a camera inside your home and taking the right footage, before reporting the case to the police.

D. Is an employer liable for acts done by the domestic helpers?

Your domestic helper brought your son to school; on the way, she tried to buy a can of soft drink for your son from a vending machine; but she somehow negligently damaged the vending machine. Would you be liable to pay for the damages for the vending machine?

There is a legal concept known as “vicarious liability”, which means that an employer can be liable for acts done by an employee if such acts take place in the course of employment. The key question, therefore, is whether the subject act was committed by the employee in the course of his/her employment or when he/she is acting in a personal capacity. In the above example, the vending machine was apparently damaged in the course of the helper’s employment (in particularly when she was trying to buy the soft drink for your son). It is therefore likely that you will have to be responsible for her negligent act.

Now consider this: you told your domestic helper to go to the market to buy some grocery; on her way, she went into a mobile phone shop to look for a mobile phone for her own use; then she negligently damaged a brand new mobile phone at the shop; would you be liable to pay for the damages? Certainly the incident happened during a time when the helper was in the course of employment (i.e. when she was going to buy grocery for your household); but is the act of damaging the phone done in the course of employment? Probably not. The domestic helper was looking for a phone for her personal use; this act was not in any way related to her employment. In such circumstances, even if she was employed by you during the time of the incident, it seems that the damaging act was not done in the course of employment; you should not be held liable for this incident.

E. Is an employer liable for debts incurred by the domestic helpers?

It is widely known that employers of foreign domestic helpers have been the subject of harassment by loan sharks because the helpers have absconded after borrowing money. Employers have to be aware that they do not have any duty at all to repay any indebtedness due by the domestic helper to any person. Anyone who claims to be the creditor of your domestic helper can only go after the helper, not you.

On the other hand, if an employer lends money or pre-pays wages to his/her foreign domestic helper, it is entirely a matter between them.   As with most contractual relationship, the parties would benefit by having a well drafted agreement between them. It is therefore advisable for the employer to put down the lending or pre-payment agreement in writing.

F. Discrimination against a foreign domestic helper?

One major component in employment law is the law on discrimination.  Hong Kong discrimination laws can broadly be classified into the following categories: sex discrimination, disability discrimination, family status discrimination and race discrimination. In respect of foreign domestic helpers, employers should be most vigilant on the possibility of sex and race discriminations.

1. Sex discrimination

One most easily encountered case of sex discrimination is of course related to the pregnancy of a foreign domestic helper. Section 8 of the Sex Discrimination Ordinance (Chapter 480 of the Laws of Hong Kong) expressly prohibits any ill-treatment by an employer against her pregnant employee.  For example, if an employer demands a pregnant employee to perform strenuous and labourious duties, that may constitute an act of discrimination.

Section 15 of the Employment Ordinance (Chapter 57 of the Laws of Hong Kong) also prohibits the dismissal of a pregnant helper from the date on which she is confirmed pregnant by a medical certificate to the date on which she is due to return to work on the expiry of her maternity leave, except in cases of summary dismissal due to the helper’s serious misconduct.  An employer who contravenes this section 15 is liable to prosecution and, on conviction, a fine of HK$100,000; he/she will also be required to pay the helper wages in lieu of notice, a further sum equivalent to one month’s wages as compensation and 10 weeks’ maternity leave pay if, but for the dismissal, the helper would have been entitled to such payment. 

2. Race discrimination

Anyone with some common sense would know that an employer cannot employ or refuse to employ a person based on his/her race.  But obviously the scheme of Foreign Domestic Helpers is to allow Hong Kong employers to engage helpers of a different race.  In such case, wouldn’t the scheme itself be a massive discrimination exercise conducted by the Government?  Fortunately our legislators have foreseen this issue and provided under section 10 of the Race Discrimination Ordinance (Chapter 602 of the Laws of Hong Kong) that it is not “unlawful for a person to discriminate against another person on the ground of the race of that other person, in connection with employment to perform domestic duties”.  This of course applies only to the employment stage in respect of a foreign domestic helper.  Any act of discrimination in the course of employment will still be subject to the laws on race discrimination.  For example:

  • if your foreign domestic helper is a female muslim, you cannot forbid her from wearing her hijab; and
  • if you make offensive racial jokes against your helper or if you use a disparaging or offensive tone when communicating with your helper on the ground of his/her race, that could constitute racial harassment.

To know more about how Hong Kong laws prohibit discrimination, please read the other topic: “Anti-discrimination”.

FAQ

1. My part time domestic helper sustained injury when she was working at my home. Am I liable to compensate her?

In Hong Kong, it is compulsory for an employer to be in possession of a valid insurance policy to cover his/her liabilities in respect of work injuries sustained by his/her employees. This also applies to employment of local part-time domestic helpers. An employer who fails to take out an employees’ compensation insurance for his/her employee(s) commits a criminal offence and shall be liable to a fine and imprisonment.

There are insurers who provide part-time domestic helper insurance plans on a daily, weekly or monthly basis. Employers are advised to make enquires and to take out the relevant employees’ compensation insurance policies.

For more details, please visit Daily Lives Legal Issues > Domestic helper issues > What the employer of a local domestic helper must know.

2. My foreign domestic helper is willing to take a salary less than the minimum allowable wage. Of course I am happy to pay less. Can we make such arrangements?

Every foreign domestic helper is entitled to a monthly salary not less than the minimum allowable wage. An employer who fails to pay the wages due under this employment contract shall be liable to criminal prosecution. Even if a foreign domestic helper agrees to accept a lower wage, an employer cannot pay anything less than the minimum allowable wage. An employer who fails to comply with the standard Employment Contract and pay less than the minimum allowable wage commits an offence. If the employer and the helper agree to a lower wage, both of them may be conspiring to defraud.

If you want to know more, please go to Daily Lives Legal Issues > Domestic helper issues > Minimum allowable wage.

3. My neighbour is travelling abroad. He said that he is happy to “lend” his foreign domestic helper to work for me for a few days. Is it fine to do so?

The standard Employment Contract for foreign domestic helpers expressly states that a foreign domestic helper “shall not take up, and shall not be required by the Employer to take up, any other employment with any other person”. In other words, your neighbour cannot “lend” his foreign domestic helper to work part-time at your place, even though you are willing to pay and the helper is happy to earn some extra money.

If the foreign domestic helper breaches this condition of stay, he/she will be liable to criminal prosecution and removal from Hong Kong. The employer, who aids and abets the foreign domestic helper to breach a condition of stay, is also liable to prosecution.

To know more about this topic, please refer to Daily Lives Legal Issues > Domestic helper issues > Other employment engaged by foreign domestic helpers.

4. I do not want to live with my foreign domestic helper. Can I ask her to live elsewhere after work?

No. The standard Employment Contract for foreign domestic helpers provides that the foreign domestic helper shall reside in the employer’s residence. In other words, an employer cannot ask the helper to reside at another place even if the employer is prepared to pay for that.

If employers or helpers breach the undertaking that the helper would work and reside in the employer’s residence, such conduct will be taken into consideration in their future foreign domestic helper visa or extension of stay applications. The applications may thus be refused.

Besides, it is an offence to make false representation to Immigration Officers upon the application of domestic helper visa. Offenders are liable to prosecution and to a maximum fine of $150,000 and imprisonment for 14 years.

Apart from living arrangement, an employer also has duty to provide food free of charge to the helper.

For more details, please go to Daily Lives Legal Issues > Domestic helper issues > Living and meal arrangements.

5. My foreign domestic helper resigned after working for six months in my home, but she plans to stay in Hong Kong after resignation. Is it legal to do so?

If the employment relationship between an employer and a foreign domestic helper is terminated prior to the expiry of the contracted period (whether it is by notice, by payment in lieu or by immediate termination), both the employer and the foreign domestic helper shall notify the Director of Immigration within seven days of the date of termination.

A foreign domestic helper is permitted to remain in Hong Kong for not more than two weeks after premature termination of the employment contract. If the foreign domestic helper does not leave upon the expiry of stay, he/she will commit an offence for breaching his/her condition of stay.

Since the foreign domestic helper is imported labour invited to work in Hong Kong, an employer shall be responsible for sending him/her back to his/her country of origin upon the termination or expiry of an employment contract by providing him/her with free return passage to his/her place of origin.

To know more about this topic, please refer to Daily Lives Legal Issues > Domestic helper issues > Termination of employment contract.

6. My domestic helper always breaks my dishes. How much money can I deduct from her salary?

The law allows an employer to make deductions for damage or loss to the employer’s goods or property directly attributable to the helper’s negligence or default. This right to deduction, however, is subject to the limit of HK$300 for each damaged item. Further, the total of such deductions shall not exceed one quarter of the wages payable to the helper in that wage period. For example, if you are paying your foreign domestic helper the monthly salary of HK$4,010, and if he/she negligently broke 5 valuable porcelain items (each worth more than HK$300) in a month, you can at most deduct HK$1,002.50 (being one quarter of HK$4,010), not HK$1,500 (being HK$300 x 5 items) from the helper’s salary for this month.

For more information, please refer to Daily Lives Legal Issues > Domestic helper issues > Some other commonly envisaged issues > A. Deduction of wages?

7. I suspect that my domestic helper is stealing from my home. I want to install CCTV to monitor her, but I am also worried about privacy issues.

The living room of your home can be considered a “public” place. Therefore, a camera installed at the living room should not infringe the privacy of anyone. However, of course you cannot install a camera inside any bathroom or the domestic helper’s private room; that would certainly be an infringement of privacy.

If you have concrete evidence that your domestic helper has abused your child or has stolen your property, do not hesitate to report the case to the police. These are criminal activities and should not be pardoned nor be settled by private means.

To know more about this, please go to Daily Lives Legal Issues > Domestic helper issues > Some other commonly envisaged issues > B. Installation of camera inside your home and C. Child abuse or theft.